☰ Menu
Join/Renew SHOT Contribute to SHOT

Joan Cahalin Robinson Prize

Update 28 July 2020
The Robinson Prize will not be awarded in 2020. Candidates who wanted to be considered for the Robinson Prize 2020 will still be eligible for the 2021 Robinson Prize, even when they present in one of the possible virtual sessions in October 2020 (You can find more information here).

Established in 1980 by Dr. Eric Robinson in memory of his wife, the Joan Cahalin Robinson Prize is awarded annually for the best-presented paper by an individual delivering his or her first paper at the SHOT annual meeting. Candidates for the award are judged on the quality of the historical research and scholarship of the paper, but special attention is paid by the awards committee to the effectiveness of the presentation. The prize consists of a check for a cash award and a certificate.

The eligibility requirements for the Robinson Prize are as follows:

(1) basic eligibility requirements

a. All candidates for the Robinson Prize must be first-time presenters at the Society’s annual meeting.

b. Candidates must be graduate students or recipients of the Ph.D. within the past two years.

c. Welcome to apply are post-docs, visiting assistant professors, independent scholars, and museum and other history professionals. Tenure-track and tenured faculty are not eligible for the prize.

d. Candidates must send the SHOT Secretary an email indicating a desire to be considered for the prize, during the call for papers process. (See below, section 4, “participant cap.”) Please also indicate in the session or paper proposal that will be submitted to the program committee via the online submission system that you want to be considered for the Prize.

(2) paper submission requirement

a. Robinson candidates will be required to submit drafts of their papers to the Chair of the Robinson Prize Committee and to the SHOT Secretary no less than one month ahead of the annual meeting.

b. Robinson Prize Committee members will not read these papers before the meeting, but will instead use them to verify that a paper has been produced and submitted.

c. Those who do not submit their papers by this deadline will not be considered for the Robinson Prize.

(3) honorable mentions

Effective 2014, the Robinson Prize Committee will have the option of naming not only an official prize winner, but also one of more honorable mentions. Those earning honorable mentions will be noted in the following year’s awards booklet alongside the citation for the Robinson Prize winner.

(4) participant cap

Effective 2016, the Robinson Prize Committee will cap the total number of candidates for the prize at 30, administered on a first-come, first-served basis. This means that if you are an eligible first-time presenter and you wish to be considered for the Robinson Prize, you must send the SHOT Secretary an email at the time you submit your proposal during the call for papers process. The Secretary will keep a list of candidates, and the first 30 to contact him will be eligible for the prize, while any others will be added to a waiting list (if any of the first 30 papers are not accepted for the conference, those on the waiting list will be bumped up accordingly). This new rule took effect in 2016 for the Singapore meeting.

Eligible presenters are encouraged to nominate themselves for the Robinson Prize: Please send the SHOT Secretary an email indicating a desire to be considered for the prize. Also indicate on the paper or session proposal that will be submitted to the program committee via the online submission system the desire to be considered for the prize.

As first-time presenters, Robinson Prize candidates may benefit especially from Paul Edwards’s “How To Give A Talk: Better Academic Speaking in a Nutshell” (PDF) or these observations from Jonathan Shewchuk.

Robinson Prize Committee for SHOT Milan 2019

Angelina Callahan, Chair
Simona Casonato
Emily Katherine Gibson
Léonard Laborie
Jayita Sarkar
Ellan Spero
Cristiano Zanetti

Recipients of the Joan Cahalin Robinson Prize

2019 Jan Henning (University of Toronto, Institute for the History and Philosophy of Science and Technology),”Opening the Red Box: The Fire Alarm Telegraph and Technologies of Emergency Response”
2018 Hyeok Hweon Kang (Harvard University),”Divine Machine: Korea’s Reception of the Gun”
2017 Thomas Kelsey (King’s College London), “The Peculiar Expense of the British Atom: The Internal Critics of the British Nuclear Power Programme, 1957-83”
2016 Juyoung Lee (Science and Technology Policy Institute, South Korea), “The Practice of Planning in South Korea’s First Comprehensive National Physical Development Plan, 1963-1972”
2015 Sarah McLennan (College of William and Mary), “Computing and the Color Line: Race, Gender, and Opportunity in Early Computing at NASA”
2014 Saara Matala (Aalto University), “The Technopolitics of Cold War Shipbuilding: Nuclear Ice Breakers in Finnish-Soviet Eastern Trade, 1984-1990”
2013 Meghan Crnic (University of Pennsylvania), “Children in the Sun? UV Lamps as Technology of Nature, 1900-1930”
2012 Rachel Rothschild (Yale University), “Détente from the Air: Monitoring Pollution and European Integration in the Cold War”
2011 Whitney E. Laemmli (University of Pennsylvania), “A Case in Pointe: Making Streamlined Bodies and Interchangeable Ballerinas at the New York City Ballet,”
Aditi Raghavan (Northwestern University), “‘The
Theodolite Coolie’ and Other British Mapping Devices”
Madhumita Saha (Iowa State University), “The State of India, Postcolonial Agricultural Policy and Pre-Green Revolution Wheat Technology”
Matthew Hersch, “High Fashion: The Women’s Undergarment Industry and the Foundations of American Spaceflight”
Kara Swanson, “Human Milk as Technology and Technologies of Human Milk: Milk Banks in the 20th-Century United States”
Anna Storm (KTH), “Interpretation Processes in Re-used Industrial Areas”
Peter A. Shulman (MIT), “Alaska: Infinite Coal Mine of the Imperial Imagination.”
Jamie Pietruska (MIT), “Every man his own weather clerk: Weather Information Systems, Local Communications Technologies, and a National Weather Service for Agriculture, 1870-1891.”
Matthew Harpster (Texas A&M University), “New rules for old boats: Proportional rules in early-medieval ship design.”
Hyungsub Choi (Johns Hopkins University), “Rationalizing the ‘Guerilla State’: North Korean Factory Management Reform in the 1960s”
Lara Freidenfelds (Harvard University), “Technology and the Production of Gendered and Classed Subjects: Tampons in the Twentieth Century United States”
Devorah Slavin, “‘Housekeeperly Instincts’: 19th Century Women Inventors and the Myth of the Ingenious Woman”
Greg Downey, “Human Labor and Human Geography in the Study of Information Internetworks”
Nina Wormbs, “A New Technology to Save Old Values: The Nordic Direct Broadcasting Satellite”
Thomas Kaiserfeld, “Mining, Manure and the Military: The Science of Saltpeter and Gunpowder”
Killian Anheuser, “Fire-Guilding–Technology of an Ancient Craft”
Barbara L. Allen, “Oil and Water: An Environmental and Cultural History of the Petrochemical Industry in Louisiana”
Greg Clancey, “The Balloon Frame Revisited: Mechanization, Mass Production, and Prefabrication in American Building-Carpentry”
Regina Blaszczyk, “Reign of Robots: The Homer Laughlin China Company and Flexible Mass Production, 1916-1948”
Molly Berger, “Leaving the Light On: The Modern Hotel in America”
Brett Steele, “A Pioneering Engineer: Benjamin Robins and Eighteenth Century Ballistics”
Meg Sondey, “An Initial Investigation of Welded Homes in the United States”
Arwen Mohun, “Women Workers and the Mechanization of Steam Laundries”
Raman Srinivasan, “Technology Sits Cross-Legged: The History of the Jaipur Foot”
Diane Q. Webb, “Two Paths to Building National Science and Technology Capabilities: South Korea and Brazil, 1960-1985”
James H. Capshew, “Engineering a Technology of Behavior: B.F. Skinner’s Kamikaze Pigeons in World War II”
not presented
Susan Smulyan, “The Rise and Fall of the Happiness Boys: Sponsorship, Technology, and Early Radio Programming”
Larry Owens, “Vannevar Bush and the Differential Analyzer: The Text and Academic Context of an Early Computer”
Mona Spangler Phillips, “Geometry in Gothic Design”
Christopher Hamlin, “Recycling as a Goal of Sewage Treatment in 19th Century Britain”
J. Lauritz Larson, “Inventing Technological Systems: A Railway Example”